As someone who receives song submissions every single day, I have seen the rise of AI-generated music firsthand. When this trend first started, it was fairly easy to tell which songs were made with artificial intelligence. The vocals sounded robotic, the production felt flat, and the emotion simply was not there.
But things have changed. AI has advanced to the point where it is almost impossible to tell whether a song is real or computer-generated. I have personally reached out to ask about the artist singing the track, only to discover that the artist does not exist at all. In some cases, I receive no reply, which is usually a dead giveaway. Other times, I am told directly that the song was created entirely with AI.
Nothing is more frustrating.
For those of us who work in the music industry, whether in radio promotion, publishing, or artist development, this new reality raises serious concerns about authenticity, legality, and ethics. If you are serious about getting your songs on the radio, earning royalties, or building a lasting career, you need to understand the real risks of letting AI do the writing for you.
⸻
1. No Copyright Protection
Purely AI-generated songs cannot be copyrighted because there is no human authorship. That means you have no legal ownership, and anyone can use, copy, or release your song without permission. In the eyes of the law, it is public domain.
⸻
2. Radio Stations Will Not Play Them
Radio program directors and Christian stations alike are rejecting AI music. They look for authenticity, songs written and performed by real people with real stories. AI tracks are viewed as artificial and inauthentic, which makes them an immediate rejection for radio.
⸻
3. Streaming Services Will Not Pay Royalties
Platforms like Spotify and Apple Music pay royalties only to human songwriters and performers. Since AI cannot be recognized as the creator, there is no royalty payment structure for AI-generated songs. Even if your AI song racks up thousands of streams, you will not earn a penny.
⸻
4. Performing Rights Organizations Will Not Pay
Organizations like ASCAP, BMI, and SESAC only pay royalties to registered songwriters. You cannot register an AI as a writer, so no payouts will ever occur for AI-only works.
⸻
5. Contests and Songwriter Organizations Ban AI Songs
Most songwriting contests, publishers, and songwriter associations now explicitly exclude AI-generated entries. Submitting one could result in disqualification, and if you did not disclose it, possibly permanent damage to your professional reputation.
⸻
6. Deception Destroys Credibility
When someone submits an AI song to radio or a contest without disclosure, it comes across as dishonest. In an industry built on relationships and trust, that kind of deception can close doors quickly. Once your credibility is gone, it is hard to earn it back.
⸻
7. Loss of Professional Respect
True songwriters spend years refining their craft. They write from personal experience, faith, heartbreak, struggle, and hope. If you rely entirely on AI, professionals will likely see you as taking shortcuts instead of mastering your gift.
⸻
8. Industry Gatekeeping Is Real
Record labels, publishing companies, and professional guilds are already setting clear “no AI” policies. They know the future of music depends on protecting human creativity and originality, not replacing it with code.
⸻
9. No Long-Term Career Value
Even if an AI song goes viral, it cannot be legally protected or monetized. You may gain short-term attention but no long-term income or credibility. Building your career on AI music is like building a house on sand. It will not stand.
⸻
10. Lack of Emotional Depth
AI can mimic sound, but it cannot feel. It does not experience pain, redemption, love, or faith, the very emotions that make great songs timeless. Listeners connect with stories, not simulations.
⸻
11. Legal Liability for Infringement
AI systems are trained on millions of existing copyrighted songs. If your AI-generated song unintentionally copies or resembles another artist’s work and you claim it as your own, you could face copyright infringement lawsuits. Because AI songs are not legally protected, you would have no legal defense and could be held financially liable.
⸻
Bottom Line: AI Is a Tool, Not a Creator
AI can help spark ideas or overcome writer’s block, but it should never replace your creativity. If your goal is airplay, royalties, or publishing opportunities, your music must be human-written and human-owned.
AI-generated songs are not just unmarketable; they are a legal, ethical, and professional risk.
Stay authentic, stay creative, and write songs that come from the one thing AI will never have: a soul.
I’d love to hear your thoughts on this topic. Have you encountered AI-generated songs or wrestled with how to use AI responsibly in your own creative process? Your insights, questions, and experiences add real value to this conversation. I personally read every comment and appreciate the feedback because it helps shape future articles and keeps this dialogue about authenticity in music alive and growing.
⸻
About the Author
Jeff McLaughlin is the Founder of McLaughlin Music Group, A-Sides Radio Promotion, INOV8 PR, and ChristianSongwriting.com. For over two decades, he has helped independent Christian artists get their music heard on radio, refine their songwriting craft, and navigate the industry with integrity. Jeff also serves as Judging Coordinator for the nation’s longest-running Christian songwriting contest and is passionate about helping songwriters write, record, and release songs that truly make an impact.
Great article. I’m glad A.I. songs are not being accepted. My wife and I vowed that we would never allow A.I. to write our songs or produce them.
Good job
Thank you
Kiwi Steve
Check this out!
https://musicrow.com/2025/10/riaa-honors-lauren-daigle-jackie-patillo-ed-leonard-marsha-blackburn-chris-coons/
Thank you for writing this article. I have been concerned about the use of AI in songwriting and it feels to me like cheating. Songwriting is challenging even when writing from inspiration and talent. It is a lot of hard work. It is not fair that some try to cheat the normal creation of songs by using a computer generated process. And they often get away with calling it their own work.
What about if the lyrics are
All my own original lyrics and am just using ai to give myself a full band .I have all my songs recorded with my guitar but the recordings are poor quality and using Ai takes my song and makes a cover , giving it a great sound . I would love artists to record my songs , i have an
Ok voice . So i see ai as a tool .
Hi Lisa, if artists know that your song has been created with AI, they won’t record them because they know of the legalities involved. In essence, you are co-writing with a robot. Maybe you wrote the lyrics, but the robot created the melody and the production, which is a problem.
Hi Jeff,
AI songs and artwork are problematic for anyone in these careers. It is stripping away the creativity and depth of real, heartfelt lyrics. Thank you for catching this rising problem in your ministry to continue making authentic songs and songwriters!
Blessings,
Celeste Talley
Can I mail you my lyrics are can I email you my lyrics to turn into music for them to sell. Your My Shining Star is already copyrighted and I am Affiliated with BMI but I am not a member. The song is copyrighted with SongSecure and you can Google it. And find my name that I will provide below.
All those measures look like a defense mechanism for someone who lost the battle. If ai generated song is good, the audience will vote. Personally, I see any popular songwriters are much worse than ai generated music, especially, lyrics, for example Taylor Swift.
Hi Jeff–
I couldn’t agree more. And as you say, let AI be a tool for the songwriter but never replace creativity. Songwriters, don’t be fooled into thinking that this AI song authorship is “the wave of the future.” Yes, using AI in production or for writing ideas is solid, but it is only the bad actors and songwriters/producers who only care about getting views and spins and $ that are enamored. Let the Digital Service Providers be your tool for promotion, not your only hope. Please center your writing around authentic relationships with God and people.
thank you for this article. I have a friend that I think is using AI on all of his songs. I have been afraid to approach him about it, but this may be a good reason to do so.
I appreciate your article very much. My question is this…with human direction for melody, meter, etc., what about producing only the music with AI and then tracking your own vocals over that? It is so much cheaper than hiring a band and recording studio. I know this from experience. Thank you.
If they are your lyrics, your melody line, and a real voice, and you are only using AI for the backing tracks, you should be fine for contests or pitching to artists. However, there still may be issues with royalties if the streaming companies or PRO’s detect AI in the making of your songs. Just be careful. I know it can be expensive, but nothing beats real human songs that have been written, performed, produced, and mastered by humans.
What about using synthesized instruments and vocals? I write the melody, lyrics, arrange and mix it all. It is not scripted AI. I have complete control of every note, voice and instrument. If we allow non acoustic, synthesized instruments for backing tracks, why can’t we use human recorded vocalists? An actual person spent time in recording phonetic sounds and the DB used my lyrics and melody to make the track.
I see the line between synth vocals and AI vocals as having the ability to edit any part of it or having it created by a scripting prompt that you can’t edit.
I read what said, I don’t think that standard practices of using synth vocals or MIDI instruments for as you stated, “you have complete control over the input”. As to your question about AI generated voice. I just read an article on the subject published by music legal expert from Kitts.ai and ASCAP. The issue is that most of the generative AI platforms using voice samples don’t hire singers to provide those samples. This leads to unfair practices when artists are fairly compensated for their contributions to another persons songs. One example of this is a recent lawsuit by the family of Tupac because another artist was using AI to recreate his voice and sound without their permission. The artist had to scrap the entire project b/c of the cease and desist order by the court. It comes down to artist’s rights, and fair compensation. That’s a lot of time, effort and money wasted.
Thanks for answering the question I asked on the same topic. I’m not sure why a songwriter would want to give up any of the rights the lyrics, melody and even the accompaniment to their song after all the work, time and money it takes to build it. The music industry is hard enough to get into and there are always issues with rights and compensation. So why give it away for free?! With regard to AI, I think a lot of folks don’t look at the 2nd/3rd order of effects as they impact the industry. AI steals jobs from studios, who can’t hire musicians who rely on the studios for their livelihoods. I just left the studio last week, and my producer said he prefers demos recorded on an iPhone with a guitar or keys. His take is that the simplicity is what leaves room to create something great.
Would love to know how to show you my recent works.
Thanks for the article, i totally agree with all that is said about the risk of using AI for creative writing. Greed is what is driven with AI and love and passion for creative writing is from God.
I really enjoyed reading this article. I agree. AI using as a tool and done right I think is fine, but I do believe all songwriters, musicians etc should keep to keeping everything authentic and creating your own music. Co- writing with others. You have to be knowledgeable and if you don’t know something that is okay. You keep studying and researching. You have to trust your instinct. AI can NOT ever replace true authentic talent. The emotion, the depth of one’s soul. As each are unique and it is always best to keep it original and work from the heart. Our experiences help also in our writing.
In this business everything changes every 4-6 months, but the basic foundation is what is standed upon. You build from there. Thank you for sharing this with us all.
Hi Jeff!
Thank you for pointing these things out. I guess if you are using AI as a jumping off point only, it’s okay. ? But I have to say, I can’t get behind using it for songwriting at all. If the words truly aren’t mine, it feels dishonest to me to put my name on it.
However, I do have an autistic, blind niece who is having fun making songs with Suno. It is a great outlet for her. 🙂
While I agree that AI is abomination for the writing of an original song, I’m not sure I agree it should never be used to create a demo, as long as the writer makes sure it renders the demo as the work tape is written. It can get expensive for writers to record and develop demos and AI makes that part of the process a lot easier and much less expensive although I agree it’s not appropriate for public consumption.
This was worth the read. I am sometimes wondering/worrying if AI could steal my lyrics for another songwriter.
Hi Jeff,
Hardly do I ever leave comments on articles, but I thought I’d offer a slightly different perspective. I consider myself a songwriter and a technologist. I’m not a famous musician or a famous technologist, but I believe I’m pretty decent at both and can recognize better technologists and musicians. I was once told that you can tell you have potential when you are able to have a vision for what good looks like and always feel like you’re out of reach for achieving it. I have never professionally pursued the music industry even though I’ve been around it my entire life. I’ve played in churches, performed on various stage sizes, been paid as a musician and volunteered as well. I love music but I wouldn’t consider myself exceptionally talented and I’m unsure if I could have sustained myself the way I wanted to pursuing music and the arts. I also have friends in the industry that are talented but have struggled with how the industry operates.
I give that background because I AM a professional technologist. I lead a large group of technologist that all worry about AI taking their role. This has been my response to them – technology either happens to you or for you. While I think everything you wrote in this article is very valid, I think there is another way to look at it. What if technology allows for people to express themselves in ways that they otherwise never could before. What if, someone like me who has the potential for great ideas, could be recognized in music competitions because I tapped into my talents and elevated them higher. For instance, I wrote a song for my mother’s 80th birthday. I leveraged AI (the way a co-writer would bounce ideas off of one another) to better express in words what I wanted. I believe I’ve written better lyrics on my own, but I thought I’d try it. The rhymes were horrible, but the concepts helped me speed up my process to get me to the “right” set of words. Then I leveraged ACE Studio to train my voice with old recordings. I laid down scratch vocals, imported them in ACE Studio and used it to flesh out the song more fully. Now, I actually can hold a tune these days, but I’m not an amazing singer. The song isn’t great and was done quickly, but it was better than I thought it would be – (if you want to check it out – https://youtu.be/H6zXPEDZiBc?si=lzLQazePpCo4xx7C). If someone were NEVER a singer, how could they get their music recognized unless they could put a great voice to it. Or if they are a great singer, but don’t have songwriting skills, could they leverage AI to get them recognized. Why wouldn’t we use the tool to help elevate our opportunities in what seems to be an exclusive club of people right now?
The point is, AI invigorated me as a musician/writer and a technologist to do more with it. In order to get something that really is great, people have to be an artist at “prompt engineering” an AI term where you describe what you want to get AI to produce something specific. It can still be crap, or it can be something really unique and beautiful! In my opinion that deserves some applause. In my opinion, disregarding something that’s good even if you take some shortcuts is like saying a movie wasn’t good because it used Computer Generated Graphics and technology, or that an electronic synthesizer is cheating a grand piano or harpsichord, or that an artist cheated because he used a picture as inspiration rather than a concept coming out of thin air, or Adobe Illustrator instead of a real canvas. This technology like all other technology is a tool that evolves how we think about art – not replaces artists.
While the industry is what it is and provides no or limited protection for AI generated work, do you think it will evolve to embrace AI or continue to resist it? Could we discover a new art in the process like we did with sampling and audio plugins. Could this new age elevate music such that crappy lyrics or poor performances stop getting attention on the radio because of nepotism alone? I think it could.
I have great respect for you making the industry your profession and I don’t want to downplay the implications of AI in music or any other industry. It is transformative and I don’t believe people should get credit for little work. What I would end with quite emphatically as a primarily Christian writer who totally embraces the faith, is that if both the rocks and AI can cry out the praises of our mighty creator and savior, I think that’s pretty darn awesome!
The issue I have is when people use Ai to produce either their lyrics and/or melodies and productions and are not transparent about it. When they claim it as “their” song without disclosing that part of it was Ai generated. And the platforms like Spotify do not require this transparency. For example, if someone purchases an Ai generated musical track they may list the creator as “studio personnel on spotify,” which doesn’t reveal anything. It appears that the artist did all the work when they didn’t. And they can generate songs prolifically – much faster than those of us who do all the hard work ourselves. Transparency should be required.
AI can be abused, and the risks are there. But for an authentic songwriter with “not good enough” vocal, instrumental or production skills who isn’t wealthy – AI offers a way to envision their 100% authentic song that is no different to hiring a producer and a backing band. Sure – humas don’t get paid in round one, but they were never going to get paid anyway. I would prefer 100% human tracks, but that simply is not feasible in the current economic environment.
Are we talking about the AI-generated songs? Lyrics and music right? The songs that were generated using some text prompts, right?
I am using a vocal synth, it can be called AI right? But I’m not generating the melody and music. I’m still using my melody and let the vocal synth sing, and I need to adjust the parameters in the synth. Is it not acceptable? If not, how about my music which I used MIDI? MIDI can also be called an AI?
Thanks
Thanks. I already checked the BMI about it:
1. Human Created without AI – PAID
2. Human Created AI-Assisted – PAID (example, asking a chatbot fo a song title or idea, using AI-powered mastering service or plugins
3. Human Created partially AI-GENERATED – PAID (Example, and AI chatbot provided a verse, and a human created the remaining lyrics.
4. PROMPT-ONLY or FULLY AI-GENERATED – NON PAID (Example, AI-generated all music with written prompts, even if prompts are refined multiple times.
I think you’ve hit on the point that Jeff was making about using the AI as a tool. The majority of the song is human created which is what really matters. Sometimes, we get stuck for an idea or lyric and the AI can spark a thought or idea with a suggestion just like if I were to ask my wife or friends for suggestions. In the end, it’s the writer’s choice to use it or change it to fit the song. In this capacity, I don’t see this impacting the authenticity of the song.
Great article Jeff!
I think it’s important, especially for Christians, to have these kinds of dialogues.
Being made in the image of God (machines are not), there’s something only his people and the Holy Spirit working through them can create when it comes to art.
That being said, the art for this article looks like chatgpt created it, so my guess is that we all to some degree or another are willing to have AI be a part of the art making process. The question is how: how far is too far?
When it comes to music, I personally have used AI to create my demo tracks. I think that distinction is important. I write all the lyrics, I sing all the melodies and I am the one constructing the format of how the chords will be arranged.
In my personal opinion, AI songs will never be able to replicate what humans can do (without a human being somewhat involved). The lyrical making ability of ChatGPT is horrendous and programs like Suno focus more on how a song sounds as opposed to the themes and words of the songs (assuming you use Suno’s AI lyric writing program) being biblically accurate or flowing poetically.
Long story short, I think it’s okay for Christians to use as test tracks but if people are expecting their AI songs to be on radio (I certainly do not for mine) then they aren’t being realistic. My goal is to get what I hear in my head into a rough track and give that to image bearers who can make it better.
The fact is this..
AI is a very fast moving train. We either get on it and participate with OUR own skills, or get ran over and left behind…with our own skills…..
Well said, Jeff. It tells me a lot about you, and that you’re in it for the right reasons.
I’m an Singer Songwriter, and I’ve gotten good feedback, so I’ll go to your website to find out how to submit songs to you. Thanks again for your insights on AI.
I read your article and think that you are on point. From my perspective as a writer. I see AI as you said, a “tool”. When I complete a song, I check grammar, syllable count in lines, etc, AI platforms can be an editing tool. That said, nothing replaces my words, my melodies or my voice.
Because I am not versed in AI, I shy away from it. Regarding platforms I’ve read about in the comments, Could they be used to 1) spark a new style idea for a song or 2) to develop demos which will later become recordings by humans in a studio setting without any legal/ethical issues?
Correct. As long as the song is your lyric and your melody for the purpose of sending to songwriting contests or for the purpose of sending demos to artists for consideration, then I’m all for that.
I am a songwriter (primarily Gospel, but also Latin grooves and a little Pop and R&B). I so appreciate this article, because I am somewhat of a “purist,” when it comes to the songwriter. I’m from an era where we observed a lot of singer/songwriters live on stage being real and authentic. While I do enjoy some of the “perks” of having AI in terms of having more insight into the business of music, I’m not sure of it’s effectiveness of truly touching the heart to heart, soul to soul, and spirit to spirit connections that are produced by creatives out of life’s experiences, times, seasons, and inspirations. As someone stated earlier AI can be abused. Somebody somewhere will want to find a way to use it for greed and gain. I enjoy my royalties, don’t get me wrong, but it is what it is!
Jeff,
Thanks for the article. As a radio programmer, it has been a challenge weeding out the A.i. music. We play a “Should We or Shouldn’t We’ song every week on our Morning show and ask our listeners to vote. I have offered several A.i. songs and the listeners reject it every time. Radio listeners Do NOT want fake music.
As a veteran of the Music industry/Entertainment since 1971 I pretty much have seen it all but nothing as egregious as AI as it pertains to music. I can name a few overnight successes, that took 10 years to get there, I’m sure you can too. This is tantamount to taking drug enhancements as an athlete. It’s a shortcut but, unhealthy and a sure way to suspension or a lifetime ban from the sport. AI should be considered the same. If you can’t compete with your talent then get out of the game. Move over.
The analogy was given me by a good friend and song writer. Norman Lee Schaffer. I told him I was stealing it.
Lou, I steal analogies from Norman frequently, so I totally get it! Thanks for your thoughts… and Norman’s. LOL!
I use my own lyrics and my own music with AI (SUNO) to create a “cover”. It’s not my voice (which is a good thing) but IS my song, produced in a way I could never do it myself. Is this original human-created content? I believe it is. What say you?
If you create the lyrics and the melody and AI only assisted with the production, then I believe that is acceptable.
Thanks. That’s my opinion also.
This is one of the most interesting threads and reads I have seen in a while. Lots of deep thoughts and perspectives. This AI music generation is new to me, and I wouldn’t lie, a promising game-changer when I was desperately seeking a way to get my music out there. I just viewed a YouTube video where the influencer was advocating against the use of AI in music production and I can see his argument as well as that of this author.
As a songwriter, I write all my lyrics and melodies without the aid of AI. I am, however, a bit challenged vocally and in music production. I have been writing since 2013 and have just about 70 songs sitting on paper and on my voice notes on my phone. One song was first produced in studio in 2020 and I managed to eek out about 7 in 2024 in a special project for a milestone birthday, which almost cost me my sanity because I didn’t have the funds to hire a great producer!
On my recent discovery of AI for music creation, I felt this would allow me to share all those songs buried in paper with ease and allow others to be blessed by the creativity through the human-written messages and melodies. Yes, I need AI to help produce the music and assign vocals until I am in a position to take what AI generates and carry it to studio to be recreated and for perhaps someone else to sing it. This is expensive, so rather than have the music hidden preventing others from being blessed through the music I write, won’t using AI for the purpose of production with AI-generated vocals be okay?
After all, we are using all manner of AI software from Chatgpt, AI in design tools etc that is basing its ability to bring solutions off of what someone would have created organically yet we’re not talking about those. Is it that we should be resisting anything that is supported by AI and find ourselves lagging or disadvantaged?
Again, I’m not for AI creating everything and people passing it off as their own, with little to no human effort. I just have a unique situation which I know many others have previously identified with. How can persons like us move forward when time, money and resources may not be in our favour and we have to give account to God for what we do with the talents he gave us?
I wrote lyrics from my personal experience in Suno. It produced a GREAT song that I love and brought my daughter (and me) to tears. If I take that song and ask a real artist to come up with their version of it, is it too late, even though I didn’t publish it yet, and I want to modify the lyrics a little more?
We’ll never hear an AI-generated song which captures the spirit, soul and hope of Petra’s “Graverobber”. The song writer, Bob Hartman, said “I had “help“ on that one.”
I played the keyboard parts on that recording.